Before you plan training
How to conduct a nursing orientation needs assessment
Compare what nurses and preceptors need to do with what current evidence shows they can do in your setting. Explore the causes of any gaps, then choose learning activities, workplace changes, or both, with a clear plan to review progress.
Download the planning worksheet (PDF)Free three-page printable worksheet. Print and complete by hand, or use the prompts in your approved planning document. No signup required.
What are you assessing, and at what level?
A course request is a starting question. For example, “We need another delegation class” leaves several possibilities unexplored: unfamiliarity with delegation principles, unclear role expectations, inconsistent coaching, or staffing arrangements that prevent practice.
- The new nurse: prior experience, observed reasoning and skills, learning goals, and support needed in this unit.
- The preceptor: observed teaching, coaching, feedback, evaluation, and access to educator support.
- The unit: patient population, uncommon high-risk situations, equipment, workflows, shift patterns, and learning opportunities.
- The organization: approved expectations, orientation resources, scheduling, policies, and priorities for improvement.
Keep these levels distinct. A unit-wide pattern needs a broader response than an individual learning goal, and individual performance should be reviewed through the appropriate confidential process.
What does the evidence and guidance support?
CDC’s 2025 needs-analysis guidance begins with the performance gap and its possible causes before deciding on education. Its Quality Training Standards emphasize confirming a need for training. These are public-health training frameworks, not trials proving a particular nursing orientation model; the steps below apply those principles to local nursing examples.
Nursing research adds context. Ulrich and colleagues’ (2025) national consensus study describes distinct preceptor competencies, offering a reference for defining teaching expectations. Catarelli and colleagues’ (2025) survey study of 273 new graduates illustrates that perceived readiness varies across tasks. Neither establishes that a self-rating, experience level, or completed course proves competence. Use local approved criteria and appropriate observations alongside perceptions.
How do you conduct the assessment?
Define a specific decision and expected performance
Choose a manageable question, such as “What prevents preceptors from giving specific feedback during orientation?” Define the behavior using approved expectations. Specify the group, setting, time period, and who will act on the findings. Avoid vague goals such as “improve attitude.”
Gather several kinds of evidence
Review available orientation records and relevant aggregate quality information through authorized channels. Add focused conversations with new nurses, preceptors, educators, and supervisors across relevant shifts. Where appropriate, observe a teaching encounter or use a de-identified rehearsal. Record the date, context, and number of observations.
A self-report answers “How does this feel?” An observation answers “What happened here?” Program outcomes such as turnover can signal a concern but cannot identify its cause on their own. Survey participation may be uneven; describe whose perspective is missing.
Describe the gap without labeling the person
Use a statement such as “In the reviewed debriefs, feedback rarely identified an observable next action.” Include strengths and exceptions. Separate “not yet observed” from “unable,” and check whether the nurse had a suitable chance to perform.
Explore learning and workplace causes together
Can the person explain or demonstrate the expected action in an appropriate supported setting? Are criteria clear and consistent? Is there time, equipment, supervision, and an opportunity to apply it? Discuss possible causes with the people involved before choosing a response.
Prioritize and match the response
Consider potential harm, how often the issue occurs, how many people it affects, and the feasibility of change. Agree on a small set of priorities and document the reasoning. This is a suggested discussion method, not a validated scoring system. Address immediate safety concerns through local processes promptly.
For a teaching skill gap, consider demonstration, rehearsal, observation, and feedback. For inconsistent expectations, clarify criteria and compare assessments with an educator. For missing opportunities or coverage, change the plan or resources. A mixed problem may require both education and operational action.
Assign ownership and plan the review
Name who will arrange each change, the resources required, the target date, and how progress will be assessed. If training is warranted, specify what participants should be able to demonstrate and how they will practice. Review both implementation and performance, rather than attendance alone.
Example: “Our preceptors need feedback training”
Illustrative situation, not research data: preceptors say they know how to give feedback, while new nurses describe mostly general praise. An educator observes suitable debriefs and finds few agreed next steps. Conversations also reveal that preceptors lack time at shift change and use different evaluation criteria.
Response: rehearse a brief, specific feedback conversation, clarify approved criteria, and arrange time for debriefing. Assign an educator to observe follow-up encounters and a supervisor to address scheduling. Look for clear behavior examples and an agreed next action, while also checking whether debrief time was available. Do not assume training caused any later retention change.
Needs assessment planning worksheet
Get the three-page worksheet (PDF)Use these prompts in your approved planning document. Write one entry for each priority. These original prompts are a planning aid, not a validated scale.
- Decision: What decision must this assessment inform, and who will make it?
- Expected performance: What observable action is required, in what context, and according to which approved criterion?
- Current evidence: What was observed or reported? Include source, date, context, and sample size.
- Gap and strengths: What differs from expectations, and what is already working?
- Possible causes: What learning needs, opportunity gaps, or workplace barriers require further checking?
- Priority: Why address this now? Consider risk, recurrence, reach, and feasibility.
- Action and support: What education or system change is proposed, with what resources?
- Owner and dates: Who will act, by when, and when will findings be reviewed?
- Evidence of improvement: What will be observed again, using which criteria? What limitations remain?
Before sharing: remove identifiers, summarize themes appropriately, check interpretations with relevant participants, and state what the assessment cannot establish. For small cohorts, avoid details that could identify an individual. Explain how comments will be used and the limits of confidentiality before collecting them.
How can rural hospitals and small units keep this practical?
Start with one pressing question and information already available through approved processes. Include day and night perspectives and recent new nurses when possible. Show counts with denominators rather than percentages alone, and avoid drawing broad conclusions from a handful of observations.
Separate a lack of exposure from a learning deficit. A nurse who has not encountered a rare transfer or emergency needs a planned learning opportunity. Regional teaching or simulation may help, while local equipment, escalation routes, and competency decisions still require local attention. Set the next review around those opportunities.
Questions educators and supervisors ask
What should a nursing orientation needs assessment identify?
Identify the difference between expected and observed performance, who is affected, what may explain the difference, and which changes are needed. Include learner, preceptor, unit, and organizational conditions.
Is a learning-needs survey enough?
A survey identifies perceptions and requests. Pair it with appropriate observations, approved records, and conversations before deciding what training or other support is needed.
How often should a unit repeat the assessment?
Review needs when planning or revising orientation and when changes or concerns emerge. Choose follow-up timing around the risk, intervention, and available learning opportunities. There is no universal interval established by this guide.
Can a small rural unit do this without a large survey?
Yes. Start with existing approved information, focused conversations, and a small number of suitable observations. Report the number and context of observations, protect identities in small groups, and be clear about the limits of the evidence.
Companion reading for preceptors
Explore the learning science behind teaching with Julia Kiss’s From Classroom to Bedside: The Educator and Preceptor Companion (2026a). For further reading on clinical judgment, feedback, specialty precepting, and preceptor wellbeing, see The Complete Preceptor Handbook (2026b). Use both alongside your organization’s policies, supervision, and approved competency process.
Kiss, J. (2026a). From classroom to bedside: The educator and preceptor companion. Transition to Practice. View the educator and preceptor companion.
Kiss, J. (2026b). The complete preceptor handbook. RN Transition to Practice. View the handbook.
Turn priorities into a supported plan
References
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2025, February 5). Assess training needs: Conducting needs analysis. CDC needs assessment guidance.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2026, October 1). Quality training standards. CDC quality training standards.
Catarelli, B., Thompson, L., Zhang, X., & Weaver, M. (2025). Evaluating new graduate nurse readiness for practice: Implications for nursing education. Nurse Educator, 50(4), E236–E241. https://doi.org/10.1097/NNE.0000000000001817
Ulrich, B., Harper, M. G., Maloney, P., Warren, J. I., Whiteside, D., & MacDonald, R. (2025). National preceptor competency consensus study. JONA: The Journal of Nursing Administration, 55(1), 14–21. https://doi.org/10.1097/NNA.0000000000001523
