For preceptors and their supervisors

How do we know our preceptors can teach?

Clinical expertise alone does not establish teaching competence. Look at how a preceptor explains reasoning, adapts coaching, gives actionable feedback, and evaluates observed performance, then agree on the support and practice that will help them improve.

Download the teaching check-in toolkit (PDF)

Free three-page toolkit: preceptor self-check, supervisor observation, and a shared development plan. No signup required.

What does the literature actually tell us?

The 2025 national consensus study by Ulrich and colleagues identifies teacher/coach and evaluator as distinct preceptor roles. It describes competencies to develop and assess; it does not establish that all preceptors already demonstrate them. Warren and colleagues’ 2023 analysis found preparation predicted the perceived importance of preceptor roles better than education or experience. That outcome concerns perceptions, rather than directly observed teaching effectiveness.

Hou and colleagues’ 2026 questionnaire study of 358 preceptors at one Chinese hospital found moderate overall teaching self-efficacy and teaching-behavior scores. Feedback and evaluation were the lowest-scoring teaching-behavior domain. These self-reports identify development needs in that sample; they cannot establish how common a deficit is in U.S. orientation programs.

A 2026 quasi-experimental study of structured teaching examinations used simulated encounters involving communication, assessment, feedback, modeling, and evidence use. It offers a way to practice teaching and examine change. It does not establish a universal training format or guarantee improved patient outcomes.

The practical implication: collect evidence of teaching from several sources. Confidence, course completion, learner satisfaction, and orientee outcomes each answer different questions. Much of the literature includes student settings or international samples, so apply findings thoughtfully to employed new graduate nurses.

Understand the nurse you are teaching

Explore what new graduates bring from school, how preparation is changing, and how to discover each nurse’s starting strengths and learning needs.

Understand today’s new graduates →

What teaching behaviors should we look for?

Use the same five areas for self-reflection and supervisor observation. Record a specific example and distinguish “not observed” from “needs support.” Avoid a combined score or pass/fail threshold.

Teach clinical reasoning

Agrees on a learning goal, explains relevant cues and reasoning, and checks understanding with an application question.

Discuss: What did you want the nurse to learn? What showed you they understood?

Coach the individual learner

Explores what the nurse already understands, invites thinking aloud, and adjusts prompts and supervision to the learning need.

Discuss: What did you learn about this nurse’s thinking? How did you adjust your support?

Give useful feedback

Describes observed behavior and its significance, invites the nurse’s perspective, and agrees on a specific next step and reassessment.

Discuss: What will the nurse practice next, and when will you check it?

Evaluate learning fairly

Uses approved criteria and specific observations; records prompting, remaining gaps, and what has not yet been observed.

Discuss: What evidence supports your judgment? What still needs to be seen?

Create a safe learning relationship

Invites questions, responds respectfully to uncertainty, protects privacy, and intervenes promptly when safety requires it.

Discuss: How could the nurse raise a concern about care, workload, or the teaching relationship?

How can preceptors assess how things are going?

  1. Before the shift: agree on one learning goal, what the nurse can attempt with supervision, and when help is needed. Ask what is still unclear.
  2. After a teaching moment: ask yourself whether you explored the nurse’s thinking, explained your own, and checked application. A nod or “I understand” alone gives limited evidence of learning.
  3. At debrief: name one observed strength and one next practice goal. Ask, “What helped you learn today? What should I explain or approach differently?”
  4. Before the next shift: identify the support you need, such as educator coaching, coverage, co-precepting, or a clearer assessment criterion. Bring the request to your supervisor.

Suggested self-check options: demonstrated in this encounter; needs practice/support; not observed. Use examples to guide the conversation, without treating the options as a validated rating scale.

How should supervisors observe and support teaching?

Agree on a brief observation of an appropriate teaching interaction, with the learner aware of the observer’s purpose and role. Follow local privacy requirements. Observe a de-identified rehearsal when a clinical encounter is unsuitable; treat rehearsal as one source of information rather than proof of bedside performance.

  • Ask the preceptor to identify the intended learning and describe their self-assessment first.
  • Describe what you saw and heard, including useful questions, explanations, and missed opportunities to check understanding.
  • Seek orientee feedback through an appropriate private channel. Explain how concerns will be handled and the limits of confidentiality.
  • Review approved feedback and evaluation records for specific observations, prompting required, and remaining learning needs.
  • Check workload, acuity, continuity, access to backup, and protected teaching time before attributing a difficulty solely to the preceptor.

For inconsistent readiness decisions, ask preceptors to independently discuss the same de-identified scenario against approved criteria, then compare their reasoning with an educator. This is a suggested calibration activity, not a validated reliability test.

A manageable check-in rhythm

Suggested local starting point: agree on expectations at the beginning of a pairing; hold a brief weekly check-in while the relationship is new; arrange a focused observation early enough to act on it; and choose the next review date according to need. These intervals are practical proposals, not research-established minimums.

Ask three questions: What teaching behavior is helping? What is making learning difficult? What support or change will happen before the next review?

What should a shared development plan include?

Example: The preceptor gives encouraging feedback but rarely specifies the next action. Agree to practice one feedback conversation with an educator, then observe a suitable debrief. The supervisor arranges coverage and a review date. Progress means the feedback identifies the observed behavior, its significance, the learner’s perspective, and an agreed next step.

  • One strength to continue and one observable skill to develop.
  • A realistic practice opportunity, with a named support person.
  • The workload, time, or resources the supervisor will arrange.
  • The evidence to review and a specific follow-up date.

If concerns persist, revise support and involve the appropriate educator or manager. If safety, disrespect, or retaliation is a concern, protect the learner and patient and use local escalation processes promptly. Do not wait for a scheduled check-in.

Get the three-page development toolkit

Questions preceptors and supervisors ask

Does an experienced nurse automatically know how to precept?

Clinical competence is essential, but teaching, coaching, feedback, and evaluation require additional skills. Assess those skills through examples, rehearsal, observation, and continuing support rather than assuming seniority establishes teaching readiness.

Is this a validated preceptor assessment tool?

No. The self-check, observation prompts, and development plan are original developmental aids. They have no validated score, passing threshold, or demonstrated ability to predict outcomes. Use approved organizational tools and processes for formal decisions.

How often should supervisors review preceptor teaching?

Agree on an initial check-in early in the pairing, observe teaching when feasible, and set the next review around the identified development need. A weekly brief check-in during a new pairing is a suggested local starting point, not a research-established requirement.

What if the preceptor and orientee give different accounts?

Listen separately and respectfully, seek specific examples, and review direct observations and approved records. Explore workload, unclear expectations, and communication. Use the appropriate educator or manager process when concerns remain; do not promise absolute confidentiality.

What should happen if teaching or supervision is unsafe?

Protect the patient and learner immediately, obtain appropriate clinical support, and follow the organization’s reporting and escalation processes. A developmental worksheet must not delay necessary action.

Companion reading for preceptors

Explore the learning science behind teaching with Julia Kiss’s From Classroom to Bedside: The Educator and Preceptor Companion (2026a). For further reading on clinical judgment, feedback, specialty precepting, and preceptor wellbeing, see The Complete Preceptor Handbook (2026b). Use both alongside your organization’s policies, supervision, and approved competency process.

Kiss, J. (2026a). From classroom to bedside: The educator and preceptor companion. Transition to Practice. View the educator and preceptor companion.

Kiss, J. (2026b). The complete preceptor handbook. RN Transition to Practice. View the handbook.

Continue the conversation

References

Hou, Y., Zhang, L., Jin, M., Li, Y., Wang, Y., Cheng, T., Li, X., & Wang, Z. (2026). Latent profiles of teaching self-efficacy and clinical teaching behaviors among clinical nurse preceptors and factors associated with profile membership: A cross-sectional study. BMC Medical Education, 26, Article 1669. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12909-026-09989-9

Ulrich, B., Harper, M. G., Maloney, P., Warren, J. I., Whiteside, D., & MacDonald, R. (2025). National preceptor competency consensus study. JONA: The Journal of Nursing Administration, 55(1), 14–21. https://doi.org/10.1097/NNA.0000000000001523

Warren, J. I., Harper, M. G., MacDonald, R., Ulrich, B., & Whiteside, D. (2023). The impact of preceptor education, experience, and preparation on the role. Journal for Nurses in Professional Development, 39(4), 191–200. https://doi.org/10.1097/NND.0000000000000822

Lee, Y.-W., Huang, W.-R., Chao, T.-E., Wen, Y.-S., Chang, Y.-J., & Lin, C.-H. (2026). Using the objective structured teaching examination to improve the clinical teaching efficacy of clinical preceptors: A quasi-experimental study. Journal of Nursing Research, 34(1), Article e436. https://doi.org/10.1097/jnr.0000000000000726