For preceptors, educators, and supervisors
Understanding today’s new graduate nurses
New graduates bring foundational knowledge, varied clinical experiences, and strengths to build on. Changes in education and licensure shape their preparation, while each nurse needs an individual assessment and support to apply learning on your unit.
Use the starting-point conversation checklistWhat do new graduates bring to the unit?
Start by discovering what the nurse already knows and can demonstrate. Areas to explore include foundational nursing knowledge, assessment and safety practices, evidence use, communication, and experience reflecting on learning. Clinical placements, simulation, prior employment, and life experience give each graduate a different starting point. These are strengths to explore individually, not abilities to assume from a degree, age, or school.
How are today’s new graduates different?
Today’s graduates enter through a changing educational and practice environment. The clearest documented differences concern preparation and context. The studies below do not prove that a whole generation is less capable, less resilient, or less committed than earlier graduates.
Clinical judgment is more explicit in licensure assessment
The Next Generation NCLEX launched in April 2023 with a stronger focus on measuring clinical judgment through new question formats (NCSBN, 2023). Recent graduates may recognize the language of cues, decisions, and evaluation. Ask them to explain their reasoning during supervised care and connect it to your unit’s patients. Passing a licensure examination does not establish readiness for every specialty task or workload.
Programs are moving toward demonstrated competencies
AACN’s Essentials describes a shift toward competency-based baccalaureate and graduate nursing education (AACN, 2026). Implementation and educational pathways vary, so ask what the nurse actually practiced and how performance was assessed. A useful teaching response is to make the expected behavior visible, provide supervised practice, and give specific feedback against your approved criteria. The framework is an educational direction, not evidence that every current graduate received the same preparation.
Pandemic disruption affected some cohorts differently
Malmstrom Zinkel and colleagues’ (2025) qualitative Australian study included six clinical nurse educators and ten graduate nurses. It described challenges with clinical and communication skill development following pandemic-era education. This small study cannot characterize all graduates entering practice today. Ask whether the individual experienced disrupted placements or substituted learning, and identify any experiences still needed. Do not presume that every 2026 graduate had pandemic-disrupted nursing placements.
The unit’s expectations are part of the picture
Nicely and Wilgenbusch (2026) suggest that perceived gaps can reflect a mismatch between novice expectations and practice demands. Eklund and colleagues (2025) show that early workload, routines, and recovery deserve attention alongside clinical skills. These studies do not demonstrate that today’s graduates are worse than earlier cohorts. They support checking both individual learning needs and the conditions in which learning occurs.
For preceptors and supervisors: ask “What preparation did this nurse receive, what can they demonstrate here, and what support comes next?” Avoid assuming digital fluency, preferred learning methods, work ethic, or resilience from age. Connect the nurse’s existing strengths to your unit’s expectations and reassess through observed practice.
What does recent research say about graduate readiness?
Strengths and uncertainty can coexist. Catarelli and colleagues (2025) analyzed on-hire surveys from 273 new graduates at one U.S. academic hospital. More than 75% reported comfort or confidence with communication, delegation, and organizing/prioritizing care. End-of-life care and independently managing codes, ventilators, and chest tubes were areas of discomfort. These were self-reported perceptions, not demonstrations of competence or evidence that complex care should be managed independently.
Unit expectations need to be made explicit. Nicely and Wilgenbusch (2026) gathered perspectives from 27 leaders and clinical educators across 14 clinical sites. Themes included professional communication, clinical judgment, clinical readiness, and professional identity and engagement. Their qualitative findings emphasize that readiness develops over time. These stakeholder perspectives do not establish a universal profile of new graduates or directly measure their performance.
Early transition adds demands beyond school preparation. Eklund and colleagues (2025) surveyed 216 nurses during their first four months at five Swedish hospitals. While 61% felt well prepared by undergraduate education and 85% enjoyed nursing, workload, pace, and ward routines presented challenges. Only 28% felt fully recovered for work. This study describes the early months, rather than the first day, and its setting limits direct transfer to U.S. units.
What this means for orientation: build on demonstrated strengths while teaching local workflows, escalation routes, equipment, and patient-population needs. These studies use different perspectives and settings; they do not establish one readiness score, a universal orientation length, or that all graduates have the same gaps. Confidence deserves discussion, and competence requires appropriate observation.
How can preceptors discover each new nurse’s starting point?
Use this suggested conversation checklist at the beginning of orientation, then revisit it as the nurse has opportunities to demonstrate learning. It is a practical aid, not a validated assessment or a replacement for your unit’s approved competency process.
- Explore experience: “Which placements, simulations, or previous roles helped you most? What have you observed, practiced with supervision, or not yet encountered?”
- Invite strengths: “What do you feel ready to contribute? Can you describe an example?” Ask about patient communication, teamwork, evidence use, and learning strategies as well as procedures.
- Explore reasoning: use an appropriate de-identified example and ask, “What cues matter, what would you assess next, and when would you ask for help?” Follow with supervised observation when appropriate.
- Find unfamiliar local processes: “Which equipment, documentation, handoff routines, or escalation pathways are new here?” Show where approved policies and support can be found.
- Agree on a first goal: identify one strength to build on, one supervised practice opportunity, the help available, and when you will review progress.
Translate the conversation into an orientation plan
In the approved orientation record, distinguish discussed or familiar, demonstrated with the documented level of support, and not yet observed or experienced. A missing opportunity is not evidence of inability. Record the context, prompting needed, next opportunity, and review date. Do not use these suggested descriptions as a score or independent-practice authorization.
For supervisors: give the pairing time for this conversation, clarify entry expectations with educators, and review whether learning opportunities match the nurse’s actual needs. When progress is difficult, examine workload, consistency of teaching, and access to practice alongside individual performance. Avoid labels such as “this generation” or assumptions based on the nurse’s school.
Companion reading for preceptors
Explore the learning science behind teaching with Julia Kiss’s From Classroom to Bedside: The Educator and Preceptor Companion (2026a). For further reading on clinical judgment, feedback, specialty precepting, and preceptor wellbeing, see The Complete Preceptor Handbook (2026b). Use both alongside your organization’s policies, supervision, and approved competency process.
Kiss, J. (2026a). From classroom to bedside: The educator and preceptor companion. Transition to Practice. View the educator and preceptor companion.
Kiss, J. (2026b). The complete preceptor handbook. RN Transition to Practice. View the handbook.
Continue planning orientation
References
American Association of Colleges of Nursing. (2026). The essentials: Core competencies for professional nursing education. https://www.aacnnursing.org/essentials
Malmstrom Zinkel, A., Rogers, C., & Hutchinson, A. (2025). Clinical nurse educators’ experience of new graduate nurses’ transition into practice following the COVID-19 pandemic. A qualitative study. Nurse Education Today, 150, Article 106672. PubMed record: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2025.106672
National Council of State Boards of Nursing. (2023, April 3). NCSBN launches Next Generation NCLEX exam. https://www.ncsbn.org/news/ncsbn-launches-next-generation-nclex-exam
Catarelli, B., Thompson, L., Zhang, X., & Weaver, M. (2025). Evaluating new graduate nurse readiness for practice: Implications for nursing education. Nurse Educator, 50(4), E236–E241. https://doi.org/10.1097/NNE.0000000000001817
Eklund, A., Skyvell Nilsson, M., Olander, A., & Sterner, A. (2025). Navigating the first months of work: A cross-sectional study on newly graduated registered nurses’ journey into the profession. Nursing Research and Practice, 2025, Article 9555767. https://doi.org/10.1155/nrp/9555767
Nicely, S. E., & Wilgenbusch, B. (2026). Partnering for change: A qualitative study on practice readiness. Journal of Professional Nursing, 65, 23–29. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.profnurs.2026.04.003
